Gas Fire Pit vs Wood Fire Pit - Which is Better for You?

Choosing between a wood fire pit vs gas fire pit can be a tough decision. With so many factors to consider such as cost, maintenance, convenience, and durability, it's essential to look at the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

In this article, we'll cover everything you need to know to make an informed decision when choosing between a gas vs wood fire pit. 

What to Consider when Choosing a Fire Pit?

Location: Choosing the right spot for your fire pit is crucial. Your decision should factor in the layout of your backyard, the proximity to your home and other structures, and safety considerations. A wood fire pit may require more space and distance from buildings based on your city’s rules and regulations, whereas a gas fire pit can be easily integrated into smaller areas. 

Budget Considerations: Your budget will play a significant role in determining which type of fire pit you choose. Wood fire pits are typically less expensive to purchase and install compared to gas fire pits. While gas fire pits tend to have a higher up front purchase and installation cost, they may save money in the long term depending on fuel costs and usage.

Intended Use: Think about how you plan to use your fire pit. For example, if you enjoy the crackle and aroma of a real wood fire for occasional gatherings, a wood fire pit might be ideal. On the other hand, a gas fire pit is perfect if you want a convenient and quick option that can be easily turned on and off for frequent use. 

Local Laws, Regulations, and Restrictions: Before making any decisions, check with local authorities about any local regulations or permits required for installing fire pits. Some areas have strict regulations on open burning flames, which might limit the use wood fire pits. Gas fire pits typically face different restrictions and might require professional installation to comply with safety codes.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Gas Fire Pits vs Wood Fire Pits

Wood Fire Pits

Advantages  

• Traditional Ambiance: Creates a beautiful outdoor aesthetic with a cozy atmosphere, pleasant aroma, and the soothing sound of fire crackling.

• Cost Effective: Wood fire pits are generally more affordable than gas fire pits.

• Campfire Cooking: Wood fire pits are ideal for campfire style cooking, making the cooking possibilities endless.

• Higher Heat Output: Often capable of producing more heat than most gas fire pits.

Disadvantages  

• Smoke and Pollution: Does not burn cleanly, they produce smoke that contributes to air pollution and that can be harmful to breathe in.

• Wood Storage: Wood fire pits require gathering and storing wood in a wood storage area, which takes up space and effort.

• Time Consuming: Lighting and maintaining the fire can be more challenging and time-consuming than with a gas fire pit where you control it with the flip of a switch.

• Regular Maintenance: Requires regular cleaning, such as removing ashes, which can be time-consuming and messy.

• Seasonal Restrictions: Some areas enforce burn bans at certain times of the year, restricting the use of wood burning fire pits.

• Fire Hazards: Wood fire pits can pose a greater risk of fire hazards.

Gas Fire Pits

Advantages  

• Convenience: Easy to light, extinguish and adjust the flame for instant warmth and control.

• Low Maintenance: No ashes or soot to clean up, and no wood to replenish, making maintenance a breeze.

• Increased Safety: Minimal risk of flying embers or uncontrolled flames.

• Smoke Free: Produces minimal harmful smoke and is considered more environmentally friendly than wood burning fire pits.

Disadvantages  

• Higher Cost: Gas fire pits generally have a higher upfront cost to purchase and install them.

• Fuel Cost: Requires a steady supply of propane or natural gas to ensure your fire keeps burning, which can be costly over time.

• Installation: May require professional installation, especially if connecting to a natural gas line.

• Heat Output: Gas fire pits might produce less heat compared to large, well-built wood fire pits.

• Ambiance: Some people miss the rustic charm and aroma of a wood-burning fire pit.

Costs and Resale Value

When it comes to costs, wood-burning fire pits generally have the edge. A wood burning fire pit may run you anywhere from $300 to $1,500 in total, depending on its type and accessories you purchase. Their affordability is attributed to their simple design, making them an affordable choice for many homeowners.  

On the other hand, the average cost of a gas fire pit, including installation, is often between $400 and $4000. Gas fire pits are available in a wide range of shapes, sizes, finishes, and heat outputs, providing you with an abundance of options to choose from that will meet your requirements and your budget.

Both types of fire pits may accelerate the selling process and enhance the resale value of your home. They save potential buyers the trouble and effort that comes with installing their own fire pit. Gas fire pits tend to offer a higher return on investment than wood fire pits, since they are considered more luxurious, eco-friendly, and safer, which can effectively attract potential buyers and possibly result in a faster sale. On the other hand, wood fire pits do also add a charming, rustic appeal to any outdoor space which may be of interest to potential home buyers.

Installation

Gas fire pits are generally more difficult to install. They require gas lines to connect to your supply of natural gas or propane, which means you’ll possibly have to hire a professional, making the installation process longer. On the other hand, wood fire pits are frequently installed as DIY projects by homeowners. Although this may require some effort, it will save the expense of hiring an installer.

The need for professional installation varies depending on the circumstances and the type of fire pit. Wood burning fire pits need only a metal ring covered with brick or stone and must be installed at a certain distance from your home. Gas fire pits have fewer placement restrictions, but require that gas lines are properly installed and out of the way.

Durability of Gas vs Wood Fire Pits

The durability of gas vs wood fire pits is heavily influenced by the materials used in their construction, how often they are used, and how well they are maintained. Whether you opt for concrete, stone, steel, or cast iron, the choice of materials plays a vital role in determining how long your fire pit will last. 

Regular usage and exposure to the elements can cause wear and tear over time, but proper care and maintenance - such as cleaning out ashes, inspecting components, and covering your fire pit when not in use - can help prevent deterioration and prolong its lifespan.

On average, a wood fire pit has a lifespan of 3 to 10 years, while a gas fire pit typically lasts 3 to 7 years. However, selecting high-quality materials and maintaining your fire pit properly can maximize its life and durability.

Time Needed

A gas fire pit is far more time efficient and convenient when it comes to igniting, adjusting or extinguishing the flame. With just the press of a button, you can enjoy an instant, steady flame that requires no effort to maintain. In contrast, a wood fire pit demands quite a bit more time and effort, from collecting and stacking wood to kindling, and patiently waiting to get the flames going. Once a larger wood fire is established, it can provide continuous heat for a good duration, but new logs will need to be added periodically to keep the fire burning. 

“A gas fire pit is ready with the push of a button, while a wood fire pit requires the effort of building and maintaining the fire.”

The time you need to dedicate to maintenance also varies between the two. Gas fire pits require occasional checks for gas line leaks and ensuring the burners are clean. While wood fire pits need more frequent attention, such as cleaning out ash and ensuring your wood supply is stored properly to stay dry.

Safety of Wood vs Gas Fire Pits

All types of fire pits require a bit of vigilance when operating them, since you are playing with fire at the end of the day.

Gas fire pits are generally considered safer than their wood counterparts. They provide controlled flames and are equipped with automatic shut-off features for emergencies. However, despite their safety advantages, it is still crucial to have the gas system checked thoroughly for leaks, follow proper installation guidelines and adhere to your local fire safety regulations. The absence of flying embers or sparks also significantly reduces the fire hazard risks associated with gas fire pits. 

Wood fire pits, while they offer a rustic charm, present a greater risk in terms of safety. Their open flames, along with the occasional flying sparks and embers produced, require constant supervision. This is especially important in windy conditions or dry areas, where the risk of fire spreading rapidly is significantly higher. Furthermore, local ordinances may restrict open burning, so you might need to secure a permit to use a wood fire pit in your backyard. To ensure safety, maintain a clear space around the pit, keep extinguishing tools readily available, and make sure children stay at a safe distance from the fire.

Gas Fire Pit vs Wood Fire Pit: Maintenance Considerations

Maintaining a wood fire pit required consistent care to keep it safe and functional. After each use, it’s essential to clean out soot, ash and any leftover logs. This helps prevent potential fire hazards. When not cleaned properly, your wood burning fire pit can accumulate creosote over time,  which is a tar-like substance produced by burning wood. This substance not only releases harmful chemicals into the air but also increases the risk of fire if embers are not fully extinguished. By regularly cleaning your wood burning fire pit, you help reduce these risks and ensure your fire pit is ready for safe use.

In contrast, a gas fire pit requires very little maintenance. The only tasks involve covering it up after use, occasionally cleaning the exterior, and removing any debris from the burner pan. Since gas burns clean, without producing ashes or soot, there’s no need for extensive cleaning, making it a much easier and less time consuming option to maintain.

Fuelling and Storage

Gas fire pits use natural gas or liquid propane as a fuel source, while wood fire pits require a supply of firewood.

For wood fire pits, you'll need to ensure a continuous supply of quality firewood. This can be sourced from your nearby forest or purchased. Proper storage is then crucial in order to maintain its quality over time. It is best recommended to store your firewood in a dry, covered area away from your home to reduce the risk of pest infestations and ensure proper ventilation. Many homeowners use a wood rack or a dedicated storage shed for this purpose.

Gas fire pits, on the other hand, use either natural gas or liquid propane. If you opt for propane, you'll need a propane tank that needs to be refilled or replaced periodically. Natural gas lines can offer a more permanent solution but come with the initial installation costs. Proper storage of propane tanks is essential, as safety regulations must be followed. It’s recommended to store them in a propane tank cover, or well-ventilated outdoor area away from any structures.

Environmental Concerns

When comparing the environmental impact of wood and gas fire pits, gas fire pits generally come out ahead. They produce fewer emissions and do not contribute to deforestation, making them a more eco-friendly option. Wood fire pits, despite offering a natural aesthetic, emit more smoke and pollutants into the air. As a result, gas fire pits are considered the better environmentally friendly choice for maintaining good air quality and minimizing ecological harm.

Conclusion - Wood Fire Pit vs Gas Fire Pit

Deciding between a wood vs gas fire pit depends on your individual preferences and needs. Both options bring unique benefits and challenges, making each suitable for different lifestyles and circumstances. Let's recap: 

• Wood fire pits: Offer a traditional campfire feel, with the crackling sound and aroma of burning wood. They require more maintenance but are often favoured for their authenticity and lower initial cost.
• Gas fire pits: Provide convenience, ease of use, and a clean burn. They're generally higher in cost but require less effort for upkeep and can be quickly ignited or extinguished.

Ultimately, your choice hinges on factors like budget, convenience preference, aesthetic appeal, and environmental considerations. Assess what aligns best with your lifestyle and how you envision using your outdoor space. No matter your decision, a fire pit will undoubtedly enhance your outdoor living area, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for relaxation and social gatherings. 

Need more help deciding? Feel free to reach out via phone at (640) 500-4847 or via email at info@fire-elements.com. Happy fire pit hunting!